The books will be contributions to various aspects of the continuing dialogues between religion and philosophy, between scepti cism and faith, and between the. Objections so bad i couldnt have made them up worst objections to kalam cosmological argument duration. Likewise, in the cosmological argument, the clause begins to exist should not mean the same thing when applied to the universe that it means when applied to individual things within the universe. Philosophical arguments for the finitude of the past. It is a pretty weak and ultimately useless argument but for some reason it really does hook. The more controversial premise in the argument is premise 2, that the universe began to exist. It builds up on sound premises but then makes a huge leap and pulls up a conclusion from nowhere which does. The success of the kalam cosmological argument in establishing an existence in god the kalam cosmological argument is an argument from the existence of the world or universe to the existence of god, i think this is effective because the existence of the universe, such arguments claim, stands in need of explanation, the only adequate explanation, the arguments suggest, is that it was created. That is an unproven assumption that is disproved by the physics phenomenon known as spontaneous pair production an example of things happening without cause, but rather happening because they could happen.
Is the kalam cosmological argument a sound proof for god. The kalam cosmological argument essay 1100 words cram. The kalam cosmological argument by theodore schick, he states that there is scientific proof for explaining the creation of the universe, but this proof also provides evidence of what others believe shows the existence of god, who to them, is the one who created the big bang that then created the universe. On the kalam cosmological argument common sense atheism. Yishai cohen raises three related objections to the kalam cosmological argument. He argues that if the first two premises are true, then premise three. Kalam cosmological argument, the macmillan press ltd, 1979, p. The word kalam is an arabic word that denotes medieval islamic theology. So i think that the first premise of the kalam cosmological argument is surely true. Oct 20, 2017 objections so bad i couldnt have made them up worst objections to kalam cosmological argument duration. Explaining the kalam cosmological argument, craig writes. Closed systems, explanations, and the cosmological argument in international journal for philosophy of religion, 2007. A summary of the problems with the kalam cosmological argument.
The scientific kalam cosmological argument reasonable faith. In professor mackie and the kalam cosmological argument, 36775, professor william lane craig undertakes to demonstrate that j. Philosophical support the philosophical arguments for the beginning of the universe draw on the idea that the existence of an actual infinite number of things entails logical contradictions and is therefore impossible. Jul 10, 2017 to hang ones metaphysical hat on the cosmological argument is to watch it sail away on the breeze. The original kalam cosmological argument was developed by islamic scholars in medieval times based on the aristotelian prime mover idea. Mackies analysis of the kalam cosmological argument in the miracle of theism is superficial, and that mackie has failed to provide any compelling or even intuitively appealing objection against. The kalam cosmological argument is one of the most popular cosmological arguments around today. Smiths most recent criticism of the kalam cosmological argument is also a denial of the. The argument is fairly straightforward and enjoys intuitive support.
Simply put if con can present evidence or argument that successfully dismantles the kalam, con wins. Consult the cited works of craig for a more thorough statement and defense of the argument. Firstly, cohen argues that, if the argument against the possibility of an actual infinite, which is used to support the kalam cosmological argument, is sound, then a predetermined endless future must also be impossible. The cosmological argument is probably the most popular of the theological existence proofs. Reviews the two volumes of copans the kalam cosmological argument, without a doubt, constitute an excellent collection of essays that for years to come will be the place to start for those interested in a profound analysis of the problems and merits of the kalam cosmological argument. Lets examine both philosophical arguments and scientific evidence in support of premise 2. Or is the material universe all that is, or ever was, or ever will be. This argument depends crucially on the idea that the universe had a beginning in time and essentially has the following logical structure. The cosmological argument is less a particular argument than an argument type. Learning objectives topic to understand how far the cosmological argument seeks to prove that god exists to understand why religious believers argue that the cosmological argument demonstrates that it is reasonable to believe in god to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the. Metcalfe abstract william lane craig is the most recognizable contemporary defender of the kalam cosmological argument. It was popularized by william lane craig in his book, the kalam cosmological argument 1979. But since i was requested to answer, heres the first premise.
That is an unproven assumption that is disproved by the physics phenomenon known as spontaneous pair production an example of things happening without cause, but. The logic likewise flows as follows and is simple in its presentation. I the other philosophical argument o ered in defense of premise 2 is that there cannot be an actual in nite in the world, merely a potential in nite. This mustread volume brings together leading edge figures to address key issues surrounding this argument and in doing so has genuinely broken new ground. Aug 21, 20 the flaw in that argument is the idea that everything that begins to exist had a cause. The kalam cosmological argument is an exercise in positive deist apology which aims to demonstrate that the existence of god can be inferred to be highly probable. The argument is much sounder than the cosmological and other similar arguments in that it doesnt build up on one false premise after another and coming to a logical conclusion based on them. Cosmological argument stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. It is a surrender to the supernatural, and a forfeiture of the labor that science is forced to endure. The argument doesnt actually tell us anything we didnt already know and appears to be a pointless tautology.
The kalam cosmological argument remains an intriguing theistic argument that raises numerous critical philosophical questions. William lane craigs recent form of the kalam cosmological argument. The second, which craig terms the kalam argument, holds that an infinite temporal regress of causes is impossible because an actual infinite is. Over the years many different versions of it have been presented. Reading religion the best possible collection on the kalam cosmological argument one. The kalam cosmological argument is based on the concept of the primemover, introduced by aristotle, and entered early christian or neoplatonist philosophy in late antiquity, being developed by john philoponus. Sound is defined as a logically valid argument that withstands all scrutiny. Craig argues oppy has not succeeded in defending the objections of grunbaum, davies, and hawking against the kalam cosmological argument.
Sep 09, 2012 the cosmological argument is therefore, nothing more than a clever god of the gaps argument. Pdf kalam cosmological argument and the modern science. I am currently mapping william lane craigs kalam cosmological argument for the existence of god, along with all its supporting arguments, counterarguments, countercounterarguments, and so on this page serves as an underconstruction bibliography of academic books, chapters, and journal articles written about the points defended in craigs version of the kalam since. May 07, 2014 in closing, i find it strange for an atheist to appeal to aristotelian metaphysics to undermine the kalam cosmological argument. Therefore, the universe has a cause for its existence. Mackies objections to the kalam cosmological argument. The first part aims to establish that there is a cause of the universe.
On guard by william lane craig 1 whatever begins to exist has a cause. Then, the usual interpretation of the kalam cosmological argument is not sound, since the meaning of c is di. An argument for god software engineering last updated wednesday, december 02, 1998 the kalam cosmological argument written not by curtis hrischuk but by some other fellow what follows is a short presentation of the kalam cosmological argument for the existence of god. I aim to defend of version of the kalam cosmological argument that. It was popularized by william lane craig in his book, the kalam cosmological argument 1979 the argument s key underpinning idea is the metaphysical impossibility of actual infinities and of. Professor william craigs criticisms of critiques of kalam. Or could it have come into existence uncaused, from nothing. Pdf we present a formal analysis of the revised version of the kalam cosmo logical argument advocated by w.
How to debunk the kalam cosmological argument debating religion. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the b. What is wrong with the first premise of kalam cosmological argument. Even if we grant, for the sake of argument, that this allows him to avoid the conclusion of the kca, he has just given credence to different arguments for gods existence e. Although the argument is fundamentally islamic, and. The leibnizian cosmological argument appearedtoblogly. The kalam cosmological argument, volume 1 by paul copan. Introduction a cosmological argument takes some cosmic feature of the universe such as the existence of contingent things or the fact of motion that calls out for an explanation and argues that this feature is to be explained in terms of the activity of a first cause, which first. Heres the kalamcosmological argument as rendered deductively by craig see included links for details. Everything that has a beginning of its existence has a cause of its existence. May 24, 2000 of the many ongoing debates to answer this question, william craig examines one of the most controversial proofs for the existence of god. Round 1 acceptance and definitions round 2 opening arguments no rebuttals. This is the kalam cosmological argument by catholic religion teacher on vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.
May 23, 2015 the original kalam cosmological argument was developed by islamic scholars in medieval times based on the aristotelian prime mover idea. William lane craig, the kalam cosmological argument, the macmillan press ltd, 1979, p. The cosmological argument for the existence of god 2. A refutation of the kalam cosmological argument for god. This paper is concerned with the kalam cosmological argument, which aims to demonstrate that the universe was created ex nihilo by a personal creator. Introduction to the kalam cosmological argument this is a particular form of the cosmological argument developed in a modern form primarily by william lane craig. The most simple criticism of the kalam cosmological argument. Kalam cosmological argument in reasonable faith, 3rd edition, 2008. To hang ones metaphysical hat on the cosmological argument is to watch it sail away on the breeze. Cosmological argument page 2 of 5 the kalem is a version of the cosmological argument coming from the islamic tradition.
A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the btheory of time curtis j. The kalam cosmological argument is a modern formulation of the cosmological argument for the existence of god. The sources used in this presentation are documented according to current. My goal is to show that this second theistic part is unsound. What follows is a short presentation of the kalam cosmological argument for the existence of god. It means i suspend judgment on the kalam cosmological argument until there is something like a consensus among cosmologists about the beginning of the universe. Therefore, the universe has a cause problems with the kalam cosmological argument.
One trouble with the kalam argument is that the more it seems to rely on science, the more vulnerable it is to science offering alternative explanations. The kalam argument popular writings reasonable faith. This is not supposed to represent an endorsement of the argument, but merely serves as an introduction to it. Of the many ongoing debates to answer this question, william craig examines one of the most controversial proofs for the existence of god. As shandon guthrie explains, the kalam cosmological argument is the product of a history of refined evidence utilizing astronomy and astrophysics to empirically demonstrate that a cause for the universe is necessary if we are to make sense of its existence italics added.
William lane craig kalam theological movement to defend islam from philosophical objections rejected by saint thomas aquinas defended by saint bonaventure o universe has cause of existence on premise that the universe began to exist. Cosmological argument, which will be the subject of this paper. Craigs argument and then proceed with the change argument. It assumes the atheory of time, which is not obviously true. Graham oppy on the kalam cosmological argument 1995 by william lane craig craigs critique of oppys defense of j. What is wrong with the first premise of kalam cosmological. Refutation of the kalam cosmological argument and others. In closing, i find it strange for an atheist to appeal to aristotelian metaphysics to undermine the kalam cosmological argument. Essay the kalam cosmological argument by theodore schick. To arrive at this conclusion, the argument employs facts concerning causation, cosmology, and contingency, as related to the beginning or coming into being of the universe. How to debunk the kalam cosmological argument debating.
Thus, the second premiss is concerned with change, and it asserts that if the series or sequence. Craig provides a broad assessment of the argument in lieu of recent developments in philosophy, mathematics, science and. Muslim theologians, when islam swept over egypt in north africa, absorbed the christian thought that had been in those areas, like in alexandria, which was. William lane craig is a theologian whom i have encountered before because of his advocacy of what is known as. The kalam cosmological argument by william lane craig. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the btheory. Proponents of the kalam argument go on to argue that god is the. It uses a general pattern of argumentation logos that makes an inference from particular alleged facts about the universe cosmos to the existence of a unique being, generally identified with or referred to as god. Kalam cosmological argument bibliography philpapers.
The kalam cosmological argument is a product of the tradition of islamic science known as ilm alkalam, which was established in order to defend the islamic faith against academic criticism. Pdf huduth argument in contemporary western philosophy known as kalam cosmological argument is an argument for the existence of. What we call today the kalam cosmological argument, was first made by aristotle and then by islamic scholars in the 9th century. It claims that the existence of the universe can best be explained by an intentional designer, namely god, since natural explanations have not been. The success of the kalam cosmological argument in establishing an existence in god the kalam cosmological argument is an argument from the existence of the world or universe to the existence of god, i think this is effective because the existence of the universe, such arguments claim, stands in need of explanation, the only adequate. It was popularized by william lane craig in his book, the kalam cosmological argument 1979 the arguments key underpinning idea is the metaphysical impossibility of actual infinities and. One approach to answering this question is the cosmological argument.
Introduction to the kalam cosmological argument calum miller. Inverse operations with transfinite numbers and the kalam cosmological argument 1995 by graham oppy in a reply to quentin smith, craig complained that smith had. However theologians have a long history of trying to do so and craig spends a lot his energy trying to provide scientific and mathematical support for the socalled kalam cosmological argument. Also, you cannot get to god from this argument the cause could be anything. May, 2009 the kalam cosmological argument for god, 2007. In defense of the kalam cosmological argument 1997 by william lane craig craigs reply to the present paper. It is also significant to note that all the argument ends up with is the claim that there is a cause of the universe the identification of this cause with god is, as with aquinas arguments. But as scholars have debated its terms and premises over the years, theyve quickly given rise to much larger questions about cosmology, physics, mathematics, and the. The sources used in this presentation are documented according to current modern language association standards. William lane craig has refined it to make it the cornerstone of his argument for the existence of the god of christianity.
Craig provides a broad assessment of the argument in lieu of recent developments in philosophy, mathematics, science and theology. Muslim theologians, when islam swept over egypt in north africa, absorbed the christian thought that had been in those areas, like in alexandria, which was the center of christian learning. The kalam cosmological argument is a product of the tradition of islamic science known as ilm al kalam, which was established in order to defend the islamic faith against academic criticism. A fallacy of cosmic proportions the kalam cosmological.
1541 24 965 1526 818 151 281 488 982 555 323 1276 1422 275 706 1107 904 486 545 222 554 698 1458 321 1103 1441 1457 599 799 1071 1117 722 1179 1010 1369 647 1087 1008 1368 970 440 991 632